If you’re anything like my family, this time of year means too many tomatoes. It is an awesome problem to have. We get more tomatoes than we can reasonably consume from our amazing CSA, Honey Brook Organic Farm, that we have belonged to for 6 years. And, for the past few years, my in-laws have maintained their own backyard vegetable garden that consistently has miraculous harvests (I’m kind of convinced my in-laws are shockingly proficient at everything) and they often gift us with more tomatoes.

What to do? I don’t know how to can (Yet – but that hobby is imminent. Stay my friend and maybe you’ll see me learn. Too desperate?). So I oven-roast. This may sound like a no-brainer to you but during my first year at Honey Brook, I carefully scored, blanched, chill-bathed, pealed, deseeded, and cooked down tomatoes into sauce. It is hot, time-consuming, alternately finger scorching and freezing, and exhausting work. Here’s what I do now.


  • Tomatoes (of any type just try to make sure your sizes are relatively the same on the same pan)
  • Extra virgin olive oil
  • Garlic
  • Sea salt

Pre-heat oven to 350 degrees. Cut tomatoes into thick slices and place them on parchment paper on a baking sheet with the skins down. Scatter your unpeeled garlic cloves in the pan. Sprinkle the whole thing with olive oil and salt. Put in the oven for about an hour — sometimes more and sometimes less depending on the size of your tomatoes.

You’re left with a tray of sweet tomatoey goodness. If I can resist eating the whole tray,  I usually put the tomatoes (with the skins) and the garlic (without the peel) into a ball jar 3/4 full and freeze in our basement chest freezer. When I’m ready to consume, I take the jars and put them in the fridge. Pay attention! This is important. You don’t want to leave out the jar to thaw because it may shatter. When I make sauce, all that from the jar goes into a sauce pot (sometimes with a can of tomatoes to extend and loosen it) and cook it down for a bit, immersion blend and VOILA delicious sauce.

My kids love it so much that tonight we ate it as soup with a little milk and grated parmesan.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Previous articlePretty things for baby puke
Next articleFor Rent
Mary Galioto
Mary Galioto is the founder, publisher and editor of MercerMe. Originally from Brooklyn, Mary has progressively moved deeper and deeper into New Jersey, settling in the heart of the state: Mercer County. Formerly the author of an embarrassingly informal blog, Mary is a lifelong writer and asker of questions and was even mentioned, albeit briefly, in the New York Times and Washington Post. She holds a bachelor’s degree in English from SUNY Binghamton and a Juris Doctorate from Seton Hall Law School. In her free time, Mary fills her life with excessive self-reflection, creative endeavors, and photographing mushrooms. Mary also works as the PR Coordinator at the Hopewell Valley Arts Council, serves on the volunteer Board of Trustees of the Lawrence Hopewell Trail (LHT), holds a seat on the Hopewell Borough Board of Health, and is a member of the Hopewell Valley Municipal Alliance.